Methods for Stakeholder-supported Monitoring and Evaluation
Urban interventions, whether greening projects, circular construction initiatives, or climate adaptation measures, are long-term commitments of public resources. Their effects are often complex, an intervention that improves one thing, such as increased tree canopy, may have unintended consequences for something else, e.g. rising property values. Monitoring and evaluation (M&E) allows knowing whether an urban intervention works. Without structured M&E, cities risk investing in interventions that never get checked, adjusted, or improved.
In a new publication, the DUT Knowlede Hub showcases seven methods developed and tested within DUT projects, in urban contexts across Europe, such as Strovolos (Cyprus), Zaragoza (Spain) and Sundsvall (Sweden). Some are ready for adoption whereas others are promising pilots worth following.
This article highlights three of these methods. Read the full publication to learn about the seven methods and use the contact details to reach out to project representatives shall you have any questions.
Using digital decision-support tools to collectively evaluate potential solutions before implementation
To evaluate urban water management solutions, such as flood prevention, before committing public funds. Using the different stakeholders’ definitions of success ensures the chosen path is feasible and supported.
The NATURGO project uses two tools: the Urban Nature Explorer (a low-barrier tool for projecting costs/benefits of NbS) and InflowGo (a high-precision AI tool for stormwater management scenario assessment). Stakeholders use these to debate trade-offs and find consensus on which solutions deserve investment.
This methodology involves city officials, water utilities, private developers, and NGOs. As an outcome, the two tools can help users to understand stakeholder preferences for deciding on nature-based solutions.
Readiness: The Urban Nature Explorer is live with a dedicated website and support team; InflowGo is operational and being refined. Both tools can be adopted in other European contexts.
Where has this methodology been tested?
It has been tested in Umeå (Sweden), Debrecen (Hungary), Piran (Slovenia), Florence (Italy) and Copenhagen (Denmark).
To know more: contact Vivek Voora (vivek.voora@ivl.se), NATURGO project.
A gamified platform for participatory data collection
To prevent green gentrification (when improving the environment increases property values) by tracking resident needs in real-time and maintaining a transparent record of vacant urban resources, thereby strengthening responsible citizenship and promoting regenerative, socially just, urban development.
The solution is the EcoUrban Composer, a platform built on GIS data with a game-like interface where citizens provide inputs by uploading geotagged photos. The platform uses a transparent simulation engine to score KPIs. Citizens and residents contribute data, validate assessments, and shape the vision for their own neighbourhoods without needing technical expertise. To ensure a fair exchange for the work done, users get rewarded with points they can use for participatory budgeting.
Using this method, residents become data contributors and municipal planners are facilitators of the data collection. As a result, the tool can track residents’ preferences on spatial transformations and an up-to-date register of vacant spaces.
Readiness: Full release of EcoUrban Composer is expected late 2026. The system’s reliance on open GIS data standards and modular architecture make it suitable for adoption across European municipalities if calibrated to local conditions.
Where has this methodology been tested?
It has been tested in Poznań (Poland), Tallinn (Estonia) and Volos (Greece)
To know more: contact Agnieszka Rumież (agnieszka.rumiez@put.poznan.pl), EDITUA project.
A Participatory Digital Twin for circular regeneration
This method allows visualising the trade-offs of urban renovation at the urban block scale through digital scenarios. It allows users to decide what is the most suitable urban block decarbonisation strategy considering its surrounding conditions.
A Participatory Digital Twin method helps stakeholders see which strategy (e.g. reusing materials from demolition, choosing softer retrofit options over full demolition, or selectively deconstructing parts of a building) works best given the existing buildings, heritage constraints, costs, community needs, and other environmental issues.
Using a digital twin at the block level, stakeholders explore “what-if” scenarios. The twin visualises environmental and economic impacts, allowing the community to flag things the model might miss, such as social dynamics or local heritage values, and to reach a context-adapted solution.
Authorities, planners, and local community representatives are involved in the process. As a result, users get a a context-sensitive evaluation framework for circular urban renovation.
Readiness: A Participatory Digital Twin is in development within Living Labs in Heerlen, Verviers and Zaragoza. The method is designed to be transferable to other urban contexts.
Where has this methodology been tested?
It has been tested in Heerlen (Netherlands), Verviers (Belgium) and Zaragoza (Spain)
To know more: contact Ana Ruiz-Varona (nruiz@usj.es), DECUB project.
About this publication
This publication is a collection of methods from seven DUT projects: B_GREEN, CABE, CirCoCreation, DECUB, EDITUA, NATURGO, and Urban ElemenTREE. The methods, tested and developed by DUT-funded projects working on the Circular Urban Economies Transition Pathway (CUE TP), can be used to involve stakeholders at different moments, from early-stage solution exploration, to hands-on data collection, and participatory evaluation.